Can You Connect Your DVD Player
To Your TV Through Your VCR?
The short answer is
YES, it is possible to connect, however, there is a good
chance you may not be happy with the results.
With a DVD player running through a VCR, copy
protection can distort the picture. This is true with 95% of
consumer VCR's. DVD players, in most cases, are not
designed to be connected to a VCR. In fact, manufacturers have
specifically made DVD players so that hooking them up to a VCR
will give undesirable performance.
There is a reason for this.
Movie studios and others do not want you copying their DVD content
to a VHS tape on a VCR. Multiple copies could be made and sold
or distributed and thereby cost the DVD authors money by
reduced sales.
What the DVD players manufacturers
have done in most cases, and with most DVD player models, is
build into these players, electronic circuits which send
signals out to the VCR during play or record. By design, these
signals cause the electronic circuits in the VCR to get
confused and thereby cause distorted video.
The
VCR synchronization and automatic-recording-level circuitry in
95% of consumer VCRs will try to adjust it's levels according
to the signals sent into it by the DVD player. What this means
is that you should get distorted images such as a picture that
cycles from very dark to normal or a loss of vertical hold or
other negative picture performance. The VCR is fooled into
making adjustments that do not really have to be
made. The end result is a form of copy protection called
Macrovision.
Depending on the model of VCR you have, and depending on
the model of DVD player you have, you will get different
picture performance. In addition, you might be able to get
perfectly good performance on pass-through operation, while
getting horrible performance trying to record to a VHS tape.
This result makes perfect sense since the automatic gain
control (AGC) circuitry in some VCRs does not start to work
until the recording mode is engaged. (In other VCRs, the AGC
circuits work all the time, regardless of the mode)
Pass-through operation means you play the DVD thru the VCR and
see the results on the TV (no recording involved). Typically,
you will not be able to record a VHS tape of the DVD and get
acceptable results. In most cases you will also not get
acceptable results on pass-through operation. You might get a
perfectly good audio signal however, meaning you could listen
to a movie on your TV while seeing a picture which cycles from
good to distorted. A small consolation.
Questions:
Why would you want to connect a DVD
player up to your VCR anyway?
If you have no intention of trying to copy a DVD
onto a VHS tape, why would you want to hookup your DVD player
to your VCR? Well, some people have had their old TV set for
years and it still works. They see no reason to buy a new TV,
but they have bought a DVD player and they found out that the
DVD player has no way to connect to their old TV set which
only has a RF coax cable antenna hookup.
One
solution might seem to be to connect the composite video and
stereo audio cables from the back of the DVD player into the
respective VCR jacks on the back of the VCR (if the VCR is not
too old) and then feed the output into the TV by the existing
RF coax cable connection going into the TV antenna jack from
the VCR. After all, you have had this type setup for years.
All you are doing is adding a DVD player as another input
source. In theory this might work, but since the copy
protection scheme implemented in DVD players prevents, in most
cases, feeding a signal through a VCR, you have to come up
with another solution.
The solution is to buy a
RF
modulator box at Wal-Mart or Radio Shack for $20 and
connect your DVD player up to it's composite video and audio
jacks. The RF modulator box has a RF coaxial cable connection
to hookup to your TV.
Why does the TV picture not become
distorted when the DVD player is connected directly to the
TV?
Good question! If the DVD player sends out signals which
causes a VCR to get fouled up, then why do you get a perfectly
good picture on the TV when the DVD player is connected
directly to the TV and not through a VCR? The simple answer is
that Televisions do not have exactly the same electronic
circuits in them that VCRs do (i.e. do not have automatic gain
control AGC circuitry). As a result, your TV can display the
DVD picture and sound as originally intended. After all, the
movie studios want you to be able to enjoy your DVD movie
without any picture distortion if you are viewing it with no
intention to copy the content.
The Basics of TV Inputs
On some
TV's, the only input is an antenna jack, a small silver jack,
usually labeled "RF", "VHF", or "ANT" which is designed to take
the plug from the cable which comes from a radio-frequency
source (usually broadcast television) such as a TV antenna,
the output from a cable TV box, or the RF output from a
VCR.
Keep in mind that, with an RF signal, the video
(picture) and audio (sound) information are all combined on
the single cable. It's becoming less and less frequent that
you find TV's with RF-input only. There are almost no new TV's
above the 20-inch screen size (or even below it, in most
cases) which only have an RF input. With some very rare, and
usually extremely inexpensive, exceptions, the TV's now on the
market will at least also have a composite video input
jack.
The composite-video input is an RCA jack (the
type used, for example, to connect the input from your
turntable to your stereo). Almost without exception, the
composite-video RCA jack is yellow and it is typically labeled
"video," "video in," or "A/V." As this type of input carries
video only, it will always have next to it an audio
input.
With a mono TV, there will be a single
white RCA jack, usually labeled "audio" or "audio in," which
takes the audio, while on a stereo TV there will be a pair of
RCA jacks, the left-channel, "audio left" jack being white and
the right-channel, "audio right" jack being red. Partly
because the combination of the composite-video input jack and
the analog (mono or stereo) audio input jack(s) carry the
picture and sound on separate lines, this means of connection
provides better quality than the RF jack, on which everything
is mixed together.
As long as your TV at least has the
composite-video and analog-audio jack set, you'll be all set
for connecting a DVD player to the TV. Even the
least-expensive DVD player will have a composite-video output
and stereo analog audio outputs (with a mono TV, you could use
a $3.00 "Y" adaptor to connect the two RCA audio output jacks
on the DVD player to the TV's single audio input
jack).
On a tiny minority of current sets, and more
frequently on older, less-expensive TV's, you'll find a model
which only has an RF jack for input.
With each
passing year, it's less and less likely that any particular TV
will have RF input only. However, if that's the case for your
set, you'll have to deal with it if you want to connect a DVD
player. Unfortunately, the problems and compromises inherent
in connecting a DVD player to a set which only has RF input
make it a very attractive option to replace your older set
with a new model, as long as you can afford
it.
Actually, if your budget is so tight that you're
stuck with a set that only has RF input, you
might want to consider how badly you really need a DVD
player.
DVD's create a finer screen image and
they have extra features, like actor bios and commentary
tracks. Also, a DVD player allows you to connect to an A/V
surround-sound receiver, thus enjoying, in your home, a
soundtrack which is similar, in configuration, to that in a
movie theater.
Unfortunately, a surround-sound
receiver, and the set of six speakers needed to fully take
advantage of its output, will set you back at least $300 ( a
high-quality surround-sound setup will cost at least $450,
independent of the cost of the DVD player
itself).
However, DVD players, as previously mentioned,
also have regular analog stereo audio output, so, if you've
already got a stereo receiver and speakers, you can use those
to play your audio at high volume levels, although movie and
TV soundtracks don't provide very accurate imaging through a
pair of stereo speakers, unless the speakers are much closer
together than they typically will be in a home stereo setup.
On a newly-purchased VCR, you can get stereo sound for ten
bucks more than a similar mono model would cost. Stereo VCR's
often sell for as little as $50.
But let's say you have
a TV with RF input only and you still want to get a DVD
player. What are your options? For about $25, you can get an
adaptor, from Radio Shack or Recoton, which will take the
composite video and analog audio output from a DVD player and
convert these inputs to a single RF output which you can then
feed into your old TV.
If the output of an RF
adaptor (i.e., modulator) matches the quality of a broadcast
RF signal, it would have a resolution of 330-interlaced, or
330i. A VHS VCR has a resolution of 250i, so the result from
the DVD playing through an RF adaptor would be improved over
the VHS resolution. On the other hand, the RF adaptor wouldn't
give an image as good as you'd get with a DVD player directly
connected to a TV, which is 480i.
Clever attempts to
route DVD players through video inputs on VCR's will not be
effective. The copy protection system on many discs confuses
most VCR's and will severely degrade the picture. This
statement is true in most, but not all,
cases.
Basic Facts of RF
Adaptors
There's nothing inherently wrong with an
RF adaptor, as long as it's of good quality. In fact, if you
run the output of a DVD player into the A/V (composite-video,
analog L/R audio) jacks of your VCR, and then run the RF
output of the VCR into your older, RF-input-only TV, you'll be
doing the same thing as if you ran the DVD output into an RF
adaptor -- lumping the audio and video together and changing
them from their original formats to a single RF (radio
frequency) output. Whether you used an adaptor or the RF
output from your VCR, you'd set the TV to channel 3 or channel
4 (whichever was unused in your area) and your TV would
receive, and display, the video and audio from the RF
input.
It's quite possible to connect a DVD player to a
TV through a VCR. However, most DVD players have
copy-protection circuitry built-in. This circuitry will cause
image degradation in 95% of consumer VCR's:
Some
problems the copy protection creates include colored stripes,
distortion, rolling, and the picture displaying in black &
white.
One way around the problem of connecting a DVD
player to a VCR is to use an RF modulator. These are made by
companies such as Recoton and Radio Shack and sell for about
$25. One example is the Radio Shack 15-1244 RF modulator
which includes a composite-video (RCA) input jack plus left
and right stereo audio input jacks (RCA). Using one of these
modulators won't let you get as sharp an image as you'd get
directly connecting a DVD player to the TV's composite,
S-Video, or component-video input, but it will provide a
sharper picture than you would get with VHS tape.
How to connect a DVD player
Hookup DVD player in 10 easy steps
See over 100 hookup diagrams
|